False Comparisons
Michael Barrier was interviewed in the Huffington Post for an article entitled " Animated Man: Cartoon Expert Michael Barrier Decries Pixar, Computers ." This article already has multiple comments about Barrier's views and the article was linked to on Cartoon Brew , where there are yet more comments. Two quotes caught my eye. "What I'd call the direct connection between the animator and the character that you have when the animator is drawing the character with a pencil on a sheet of paper, it simply doesn't have an equivalent as far as I'm aware, or if it has an equivalent, it's much harder to establish." I've already attempted to debunk this based on the techniques of both drawn and computer animation. My opinion hasn't changed. It's not the technique, it's how the production is organized. Should a cgi feature want a strong connection between animator and character, there is no technical reason why it couldn't be ...